06
Mar
2021

Inept judges score Adrien Broner round without a single punch landing

Phil Jay 23/02/2021
Adrien Broner Jovanie Santiago

Amanda Westcott

Two incompetent judges handed Adrien Broner a scored round over his opponent on Saturday without an actual punch landing in anger.

Broner is back. This fact we know, but how the former world champion returned to action is up for considerable debate.

Looking old and way beyond his 31 years, ‘The Problem’ took on undefeated Jovanie Santiago. For all intends and purposes, we knew Santiago was on-a-hiding to nothing.

Adrien Broner needed a win with multi-million dollar fights at stake, and he got it by any means necessary.

Tom Carusone and Peter Hary hang your heads in shame. Not only did you miss a punch landing from Broner, but you also missed Santiago scoring with three.

At best, the only argument you could come anywhere near would be to give a shared round, although that’s coming at a big push.

Santiago landed three, Broner didn’t score. It’s tough to justify those scores. Third judge Glenn Feldman deserves some credit for coming to the correct 10-9 conclusion.

But you cannot justify Feldman giving Broner the third round when punches landed were 18-4 in favor of Santiago.

And all three gave the fifth to Broner despite Santiago landing more than twice as many punches.

In fact, in eleven of the twelve rounds, Santiago did more work and out-scored Broner in the punch department.

Quite astonishing that Santiago only took ten sessions on the tallies from 36 rounds with the officials.

None of the judges should get off scot-free. They should need to get hauled in for questioning on how they saw the fight for Broner.

Adrien Broner
Amanda Westcott

ADRIEN BRONER SUMMARY

CompuBox, in their summary, said: “Adrien Broner landed 35 of 138 punches over the first six rounds of the fight.

“Jovanie Santiago landed 93 of 305 punches over the same time frame.

“Over the last half of the fight, Broner landed 63 of 300 punches while Santiago landed 114 of 392 total blows.

“The ninth round was Broner’s most active, which saw him land 12 of 38 punches. Santiago landed 18 of 57 punches in that round.


“In the 12th and final round, Santiago landed 32 of 95 punches, and Broner landed 7 of 34 punches.”

The last line seems unjustified, given that CompuBox put the stats together.

“Though outworked over the entirety of the fight, Broner landed quality punches over the second half of the bout.

“This is why the judges awarded him a unanimous decision.”

Broner Santiago CompuBox

Is it worth a boxer landing a scoring punch if that punch doesn’t get scored? – Is it quality or quantity or both?

You decide.

Phil Jay is the Editor of WBN. An Auxiliary member of the Boxing Writers Association of America since 2018. Follow on Twitter @PhilDJay.