Munguia v Hogan: Re-scoring, post-fight drug test farce and shock video

📸 Stacey Verbeek

The debate continues to rumble into boxing judges following the recent controversial decision between Jaime Munguia and Dennis Hogan in Mexico.

Since the fight on April 13, which Munguia won via majority decision, the integrity of the sport has once again come into question.

READ: Judges, due to poor decisions, are changing the course of boxing history

Munguia was out-scored by Hogan in at least seven, possibly eight of the rounds. But it was the home fighter who retained his WBO super-welterweight belt.

Fans and boxing personnel alike have voiced their displeasure at the continuing trend of bad scoring.

Higher profile bouts have also been the victim in recent years. Both Gennady Golovkin v Canelo Alvarez and Deontay Wilder v Tyson Fury have been the subject of doubt over judging.

The competence of the officials is certainly one of the major talking points which can be improved.

Since the Munguia v Hogan backlash, the WBO has finally accepted that the scoring should be reviewed.

A WBO panel will now go through each round in order to clarify how Munguia got the verdict.

In a further twist, Kevin Iole of Yahoo News has uncovered that no drug testing was carried out post-fight.

“There was supposed to be testing,” Valcárcel told Yahoo Sports. “But the lab didn’t show up.”

Asked whether this would affect the scoring scenario, Paco added: “Not based on that. We have to presume the guy (Munguia) was clean.

“He has no history of any issues. The testing should have been done. But the lab didn’t show up. So there was nothing that could be done.”

Iole also posted a video which is set to used by Hogan’s team in order to prove pressure was put on the judges to score for Munguia.


In what are quite serious accusations, Hogan’s representatives are hoping the clip will be investigated.

All in all, it’s yet again a black eye for boxing. Constant issues with the judges’ capability are overshadowing what should be great events.

Fans and promoters cannot rely on the correct outcome following an exciting battle. It’s been this way since scoring began.

Something needs to change…and soon.